“Managers who pressurise their staff to go that extra mile risk harming their employees’ health,” the Daily Mail reports.
New research suggests “transformational managers” – charismatic high achievers – may increase levels of sickness in the workforce.
Supporters of transformational management would say it combines individual charisma and the ability to motivate staff and stimulate employees with being able to gauge the strength and weaknesses of staff members on an individual basis.
A poster boy for transformational management would be the late Steve Jobs of Apple fame.
But playing devil’s advocate, you could argue that some managers who try to adopt this style fail to get their approach right, and it’s more intimidation than motivation.
Think of the fictional boss from hell, Miranda Priestly, as played by Meryl Streep in the film The Devil Wears Prada.
Researchers followed Danish postal workers for three years. Those with line managers displaying a transformational leadership style had more sick days off work a year later – about four days more a year. The link was not seen in the subsequent year.
They report some staff members were coming into work even though they were ill – what’s known as presenteeism. This could exacerbate health problems and lead to long-term problems with productivity.
So overall, this study shows that transformational leadership may have a dark side, but needs more investigation so we can better understand the link. A longer-term assessment of the effects of presenteeism would also be useful.
http://www.nhs.uk/news/2016/04April/Pages/Transformational-managers-may-be-bad-for-workplace-health.aspx